Critical Issue Analysis - 1158 Words

University of Phoenix Material Critical Issue Analysis After reading the selected critical issue, use the following questions to analyze the issue. Issue 3 – Is Psychological Debriefing a Harmful Intervention for Survivors of Trauma? 1. What are at least two facts presented by each side of the critical issue? Devilly Cotton who represent the con side of the agreement present many different facts. Two that stand out is: that psychological debriefing â€Å". . . more of a â€Å"moral maintenance† intervention qua gesture of employer support, rather than a clinical intervention influencing distress and clinical symptomatolgy. (Halgin, 2009, p. 68.) Devilliy Cotton also point to the fact it is a company’s way to protect again†¦show more content†¦What are some of the weaknesses? I believe the strength of Davilly and Cotton was that they took the time to define and try to show the differences between Critical Incident Stress Debriefing and Critical Incident Stress Management. As well as defining what psychology debriefing entails. Their weakness would be it was how to read, it did not flow easy for the readers and somewhat confusing. Also another weakness which was pointed out by Mitchell was that they did not seem to do much deep research for other papers written on the topic. 5. How credible were the authors of each argument? Explain your answer. Davilly Cotton when to detail on what psychological debriefing was and how there are many different forms of it with: Critical Incident Stress Debriefing and Critical Incident Stress Management. Also how these two really kind of play hand in hand and might be the same thing. Therefore it is hard to tell the difference between the two. They tried to break down how these two systems work and the outcomes of such programs. Mitchell was credible in from the first paragraph notes that â€Å"In 1983 I wrote the first article ever written on Critical Incident Stress Debriefing. . . â€Å" (Halgin, 2009, p. 78). Uses the programs during an event rather than after. 6. Based on the statements presented in this critical issue, which author do you agree with? Why? While both sides had concrete evidence supporting their claims; I thinkShow MoreRelatedCritical Analysis of Staffinf Issues in Hsbc18114 Words   |  73 PagesCritical Analysis of Selection Process and Staffing Issues of HSBC UK Bank Table of Contents Executive Summary: 4 CHAPTER 1 5 1. Introduction 6 1.1. Company Profile: 12 1.2. Research Aim and Objectives 14 1.3. Research Question 14 1.4. Scope of the Study 15 1.5. Research Aim 15 1.6. Significance of Study 16 CHAPTER 2 18 2. Literature Review 19 2.1. Importance of Human Resource Management in an Organization: 20 2.2. Importance of Human Resource Management for theRead MoreCritical Analysis Of Communication And Ethical Issues2797 Words   |  12 PagesCRITICAL ANALYSIS OF COMMUNICATION AND ETHICAL ISSUES IN THE SOUTHERN CROSS HEALTH SYSTEMS ! ! ! ! ! Author: Lareb. Azam. Cheema; Communication Consultant Authorised by: Southern Cross Health Systems’ Board of Directors Date completed: 25 September 2014 !1 ï ¿ ¼! TABLE OF CONTENTS EXECUTIVE SUMMARY 3 1. INTRODUCTION 4 2. CORPORATE IDENTITY AND CULTURE 5 2.1. CORPORATE IMAGE 5 2.2. CORPORATE CULTURE AND LEADERSHIP STYLES 5 2.3. CORPORATE SOCIAL RESPONSIBILITY 6 2.3.1. BRIBES 6 2.3.2. ROKEACH’S VALUE SYSTEMRead MoreIdentification And Analysis Of Critical It Issues Facing Business1507 Words   |  7 PagesThis paper s theme is the identification and analysis of critical IT issues facing business. The content of investigation and analysis will include three key corporate IT issues, methods of problem identification, and the rationale for selecting the issues. This overriding critical IT issue facing the Fox Television network and cable affiliates is disaster recovery. The organization of the three topics explored the problem, the investigation of the situation, and resulted in a solution. ManyRead MoreCritical Analysis of Problems and Issues in Education Essay examples1547 Words   |  7 Pagesstudents were compared with â€Å"public school students with similar backgrounds. They found that voucher students had reading scores 3 percentile points higher and math scores 5 percentile points higher, in their third year† (National Center for Policy Analysis CEO America [NCPACA], 1998). They also found in their fourth year these â€Å"students had reading scores 5 percentile points higher and math scores 12 percentile points higher† (NCPACA,1998). These statistics certainly support the fact that studentsRead MoreA Critical Discourse Analysis ( Cda ) And Argumentation Theory860 Words   |  4 Pages The current empirical study constitutes a critical discourse analysis of part of the discourse that surrounds the New Caledonian independence issue. It aims to explore audience response to political speeches, to investigate how politicians attempt to persuade people to follow a particular course of action, to link the notions of discourse and action to the cognitive dimensions of ideology and presuppositions, to further clarify various contextual factors, such as power configurations, to describeRead MoreCritical Analysis of an Article on HIV/AIDS Prevention Issues for Women970 Words   |  4 PagesIntroduction: This review is about the main points, gaps and critique of the article. The main information provided in this review will help you gain new insight on women HIV/AIDS prevention issues. As a society, we focus on individualist ways of prevention. We try to enforce and educate individuals on HIV/AIDS prevention on an individual level but it’s more complex because women have a lower status compared to men, this disempowerment can lead to violence in relationships with men therefore, negotiatingRead MoreUse Of Technology And Digital Devices2192 Words   |  9 Pagesat how students and teachers view the use of digital devices in classrooms, ethnography using participant observation to assess how students and teachers interact in digital and non digital environments. To further answer this question discourse analysis would be applied to understand how technological devices are viewed and subverted by language. Undertaking this research will allow schools to provide students with t he best possible learning tools to potentially enhance their education and prospectsRead MoreAdvertisements : How Do They Persuade Us ?3275 Words   |  14 Pagesadvertisements and the ways in which they persuade us. There are many approaches to this end, but we will draw upon two: semiology, or the study of signs, and content analysis. Semiology, on the one hand, is concerned with the emergence and â€Å"movement† of meaning within the text and between the text and the world surrounding it. Content analysis, on the other, focuses on the surface meaning of an ad, detecting similarities and differences. Indisputably, the growing predominance of visuals in adsRead MoreA Critical Analysis of the Key National Security Issues Faced in the Post-Vietnam War Period566 Words   |  3 PagesA Critical Analysis of the Key National Security Issues Faced in the Post-Vietnam War Period There have been a lot of developments that happened during the Vietnam War that concerns the key national security issues of the country. However, there are an also a lot of significant changes that occurred after that historical event, that forever changed the policy conceptualization and implementation of national and foreign-related issues. The administration of Richard Nixon was greatly affected byRead MoreA critical analysis of Tanzanite I’s service recovery issue – A study related to Jain University’s2700 Words   |  11 Pages A critical analysis of Tanzanite I’s service recovery issue – A study related to Jain University’s international visit to Milan. Table of contents 1. Introduction 2 2. Literature review 3 2.1 Service Recovery Paradox 4 2.2 Customer Responses to Service Failures 4 2.3 Conceptual model 5 2.4 Impact of culture 5 3. Analysis 6 3.1 Failure Context 6 3.2 Magnitude of Failure 7 3.3 Recovery Attributes 7 3.4 Cross-cultural